Bill Luke Tempe
An Alfa Romeo Tonale vs. Stelvio comparison is necessary because both models have an array of advantages to consider. For example, the Tonale is the smaller of the two SUVs, yet it has a larger trunk and more towing capacity. The Stelvio also entices, thanks to a stronger engine, more expansive maximum cargo space, and comparable MPG ratings – despite being the larger automobile. At Bill Luke Tempe, our team is proud to field both of these luxurious SUVs.
We begin with what's under the hood. As both SUVs are under the Alfa Romeo banner, the engines are responsive and capable. A 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-four-cylinder engine revs to life in each SUV; both capable and efficient powertrains come with standard AWD.
However, how that powertrain performs varies across these two sporty models. The new Alfa Romeo Stelvio for sale is tuned to produce 280 horsepower and 306 pound-feet of torque; this engine is paired with an eight-speed automatic transmission. Meanwhile, the Tonale outputs 268 horsepower and 295 pound-feet of torque; its engine is paired with a slightly smoother nine-speed automatic transmission.
| Alfa Romeo Tonale | Alfa Romeo Stelvio | |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | 2.0L turbo I-4 | 2.0L turbo I-4 |
| Horsepower | 268 | 280 |
| Torque | 295 lb-ft | 306 lb-ft |
| Transmission | 9-speed auto | 8-speed auto |
| Drivetrain | AWD | AWD |
| EPA-Est. MPG (City / Hwy / Cmb) | 21 / 29 / 241 | 22 / 28 / 242 |
| Towing Capacity | 3,307 lbs3 | 3,000 lbs3 |
| Length | 178 in | 184.6 in |
| Width (w/mirrors) | 82 in | 85.1 in |
| Height | 63 in | 66 in |
| Cargo Capacity (Trunk / Max) | 27 / 54.7 cu ft | 18.5 / 56.5 cu ft |
No matter the SUV you select, the Alfa Romeo Tonale and Stelvio are responsive: the Stelvio has just a minor advantage on acceleration, while the Tonale is the stronger towing model.
As you can see in the above chart, the new Alfa Romeo Tonale for sale is the smaller SUV. Thanks to careful design, the Tonale cargo space maxes out at 54.7 cubic feet – surprising for a compact SUV of 178 inches. That combination of a versatile stowage area and the compact Tonale dimensions makes this vehicle the best pick for driving around cities.
The Stelvio trunk space is slightly smaller than the Alfa Romeo Tonale's rear storage area, but it has the maximum cargo capacity to compensate, at 56.5 cubic feet. With 184.6 inches of length and 85.1 inches of width, the Stelvio dimensions are better suited for those who prefer the driving style of a larger SUV, with its wider stance and longer wheelbase.
Customization is another key metric that changes between the Alfa Romeo Tonale and Stelvio. That's because each model has different trim levels. The Tonale has three:
As a result, the Tonale interior varies: The standard Sprint model has Biscotto stitched seating, while the Sport Speciale boasts exclusive Ice inserts. The cabin is always minimalist and intimate, a non-cluttered cockpit that welcomes you for long drives down the beach and commutes to work alike. Your exterior can be adorned with eight distinctive colors, including Verde Monza and Rosso Brera, that capture your personality through a carefully crafted design.
Meanwhile, the Stelvio has two levels.
The Stelvio interior is slightly less varied than that of the Tonale, but you'll immediately notice its premium luxury amenities. The standard Stelvio comes with leather-trimmed seats, 10-way power seats, and a heated steering wheel. The unique Dark V Scudetto Grille is the start of your exterior experience, though the Stelvio only comes with seven exterior colors to choose from, with many shades that match the distinctive styles offered by the Tonale.
Safety is a priority for both SUVs. Tonale reliability begins with features like Adaptive Cruise Control and Traffic Sign Recognition, while available features include the Active Assist Package, which grants even higher-end luxuries for every mile. Stelvio reliability is much the same, with Front and Rear Park Assist standard and a Limited Slip Rear Differential available at the Veloce level.
Overall, while the Stelvio has a minor edge in features, both SUVs will be comfortable, safe, and genuinely unforgettable.
If you weren't able to figure out which SUV deserves a spot in your garage, let us help you. Our experienced representatives will gladly take you on a tour of all Alfa Romeo vehicles for sale, letting you choose your favorite versions of the Tonale and Stelvio. You'll go on a guided test drive, receive an explanation of the features, and fully understand the distinctive advantages of each model.
So please, let our team give you all the information you need to make a confident decision on your next travel companion.
No, the Alfa Romeo Tonale is not bigger than the Stelvio. The Stelvio is the longer model, measuring 184.6 inches, compared to the 178-inch-long Tonale. However, the cars have similar storage capacity (the Tonale trunk space is the larger of the two, while the maximum Stelvio cargo space is greater), and the Tonale offers slightly more towing capacity, making either choice feel spacious and capable.
Surprisingly, both the Alfa Romeo Tonale and Stelvio share similar fuel efficiency ratings. With an EPA-estimated 24 MPG (Combined)1,2 each, the Tonale and Stelvio achieve impressive standards for all-gasoline SUVs. There are just minor differences between city and highway MPG ratings (with the Tonale being slightly more efficient on the highway while the Stelvio has a slight advantage in cities).
While both models have similarly impressive and responsive engines, the Stelvio does have the edge in performance. With its 280-horsepower 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine creating 306 pound-feet of torque, the Stelvio can reach 60 mph in just 5.5 seconds. The Tonale is close behind, making 268 horsepower and 295 pound-feet of torque.
1EPA-estimated 21 city MPG / 29 highway MPG with 2.0-liter turbocharged I-4 and 9-speed automatic transmission. Actual mileage may vary.
2EPA-estimated 22 city MPG / 28 highway MPG with 2.0-liter turbocharged I-4 and 8-speed automatic transmission. Actual mileage may vary.
3When properly equipped. See dealer for details.
